There is no arguing that SoftICE was a superior product to both wdeb386 and windbg.
Really? Well, I’m here to argue. It’s what I do best
Ignoring the fact that we’re all necroposting (a plague that’ll be fixed on the new site, hallelujah)… I personally never found SoftIce to be anything but a collection of highly version-specific reverse engineered hacks and hooks (though some of them rather clever). Chasing updates to match a given system version was super annoying. Far from “beautiful”, I found the UI to be to be obscure and out of date even for the time.
I always had a license, always hated every aspect of it, and was deeply thankful for WinDbg even from its earliest versions. I just could never “take” to SoftIce, and was even more annoyed by Numega’s greedy licensing practices for the last few versions.
Having said that, there were people who loved it, and could make it sing. I’ll never forget Russinovich expertly piloting SoftIce though some obscure Windows disassembly, and popping out of his office every five minutes or so to share his latest discovery.